OK, so here is my rebuttal and clarification of the FACTS in the FBI story.
1. I didn't "forget" about the check. When Arlene called me, I thought she said that a woman called saying that she had a $1oK check written out TO US, which is a very typical scam technique (I get emails regularly telling me I have a check for over a million dollars sitting in some foreign country).
2. As soon as I talked to the woman and she said she had a check I HAD WRITTEN out for $10K, I immediately knew what check she was talking about. Last fall semester (a year ago) in my mission prep class, I asked who could use a check to cover their entire mission expenses. I made out a check to the first student who raised his hand, then I had a different student sign the check using his own name and signature.
3. The purpose for the whole thing was as a lead-in for a discussion on priesthood authority and the concept of "power of attorney:" that missionaries (and all other priesthood holders) have real power to bind God into a covenant relationship with others. My check to the students was non-binding because the signer had NO AUTHORITY to sign and thus bind ME into an obligation to pay, any more than a Baptist minister can bind God into a covenant with one of his parishoners.
4. Because the check was signed by the other student (something I very deliberately did) I knew that there was NO WAY that I would lose $10K [if I had such a sum in the bank - which I DON'T], because I never signed the check.
5. Finally, even if I did have $10K in the bank and the check was indeed cashed, the bank would be liable to reimburse me the money since without MY signature (which COULD NOT BE FORGED, since I made sure there was a clearly different name and signature on the check) the check was NOT a legal financial instrument.
All that having been said, I should not have let the student keep the check on the off chance that a year laterit would fall out of his scriptures, be found by a student, and cause my poor beloved wife to call the FBI!
Showing posts with label And now...the Rest of the Story. Show all posts
Showing posts with label And now...the Rest of the Story. Show all posts
Thursday, September 25, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)